57 résultats trouvés

par RogerGreenwood
lun. 14 sept. 2020 21:58
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Linear doctrine requirements
Réponses : 9
Vues : 246

Re: Linear doctrine requirements

I did.
par RogerGreenwood
mar. 8 sept. 2020 22:49
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Terrain Placement
Réponses : 2
Vues : 126

Terrain Placement

Anyone else finding it difficult to position terrain according to the rules? We have 4cm bases and a 4cm UD but place small pieces of terrain using the 3cm UD measures. It is nearly always a problem getting the positioning to obey the rules.
par RogerGreenwood
lun. 7 sept. 2020 15:40
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Timing of C in C points allocation
Réponses : 5
Vues : 167

Re: Timing of C in C points allocation

You understood correctly. I am suggesting that during a division's activation phase the C in C will transfer CP whenever the division commander runs out of them. My opponent wanted me to transfer them before the unit activations began.
par RogerGreenwood
lun. 7 sept. 2020 15:35
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Battery safe flanks
Réponses : 3
Vues : 267

Re: Battery safe flanks

I will need to check the rules, but I think a unit can only give rear support to one unit.
par RogerGreenwood
ven. 4 sept. 2020 15:32
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Timing of C in C points allocation
Réponses : 5
Vues : 167

Timing of C in C points allocation

My opponent suggested that when the C in C allocates CP to division commanders he must do so immediately after the commander rolls. I disagree. I think he can give his CP as the need arises. Any opinions?
par RogerGreenwood
lun. 31 août 2020 12:39
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Artillery fire
Réponses : 4
Vues : 1114

Re: Artillery fire

The rules permit artillery to fire, limber and move. This would only be an option if they fire in the preparatory phase. One presumes that you declare this when firing so you cannot get the stationary bonus.
par RogerGreenwood
jeu. 27 août 2020 20:05
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Stupid status question
Réponses : 10
Vues : 627

Re: Stupid status question

As I read it, compare morale first. So L4 beats L2 by 2.
If morale is equal compare status. E.g. E3 beats L3 by 1.
par RogerGreenwood
mer. 1 juil. 2020 23:11
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Roundshot ricochet from uphill
Réponses : 3
Vues : 548

Re: Roundshot ricochet from uphill

I cannot remember where I read it. However, I remember something about the ball plunging downward digs in to the ground. I suppose it is like the difference between skimming a pebble across a pond and lobbing it in.
par RogerGreenwood
jeu. 25 juin 2020 18:59
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Charges, moves and passage of lines
Réponses : 24
Vues : 3572

Re: Charges, moves and passage of lines

I feel I need to open an old wound here. I have been reading the rules again and can see another interpretation. I believe I was wrong in my previous statements. Does the following make sense? The start of the rules about charging state that it is a move attempting to end in contact. It can be made ...
par RogerGreenwood
mar. 26 mai 2020 11:44
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : First text of the Intro Scenario
Réponses : 4
Vues : 880

Re: First text of the Intro Scenario

Nice to read your report. We were finding there was quite a lot of flicking through the rule book. It does have some layout issues. However, looks to be the best set of popular rules and we are sticking with them.