Bataille Empire

Strictly I do not see an answer.

I have an opinion, but I cannot find a rule support for that opinion.

As I am on a rant about this with nothing better to do :evil: If, by the same interpretation, skirmishers not being able to charge ... Yes. And its a good rant and not automatically wrong. :evil: However, I could argue that making it harder to bring in skirmishers, makes the desire/need for more CP...

There is no such thing as a group charge move in BE. There is only a group move. Some of the units in the group may be intending to end in contact. These units are charging and are subject to limitations and restrictions. What the rest of their group do is only subject to the group movement rules. ...

zeitoun a écrit : ↑

mer. 16 févr. 2022 13:02

If the one loss unit retreat in good order did the other one have to test ???

So I have checked and if the unit retreats 2 UD by choice after passing, then the other unit no longer needs to test.

I agree units don't need to physically end in contact. For example they may end in support.
I just think that the specific prohibition of artillery being involved in a charge prevents them from going along for the ride for 1 CP.

zeitoun a écrit : ↑

lun. 21 févr. 2022 08:57

currently nowhere

we try to note this in the new FAQ asap.

regards

I believe El Kreator stated this at some point on the forum.

hate to disagree with my esteemed friend Greenwood, but p 42, "limitations" 3rd bullet.

If the 1 CP is a charge move, then i suspect no.

Adrian Steer a écrit : ↑

sam. 12 févr. 2022 13:35

Seems reasonable although not specifically mentioned in the rules and its what we've been doing. I notice limbered artillery can do oblique move, I knew there must be a reason for staying limbered at long range.

You do know you cannot fire while limbered?

I think I see what is tangled and you have some solid solutions. I have tipped the hat up the food chain to ask.

I plan to tinker with your proposal to see what I think about it. It may be simpler. It does allow some ability to dodge intervening units which makes be cautious.