92 résultats trouvés

par gibbyj
jeu. 21 mai 2020 20:56
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Artillery shotting
Réponses : 3
Vues : 4838

Re: Artillery shotting

Yes 2 different calculations.
par gibbyj
sam. 16 mai 2020 17:41
Forum : Questions
Sujet : Charge and more....
Réponses : 7
Vues : 8166

Re: Charge and more....

Im not so sure.
par gibbyj
sam. 16 mai 2020 11:57
Forum : Questions
Sujet : Charge and more....
Réponses : 7
Vues : 8166

Re: Charge and more....

If B is counter charging A , I don't see that C can counter charge, its not the target of a charge.
cheers
Jim
par gibbyj
dim. 10 mai 2020 09:38
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Can detached skimmers move with an action marker
Réponses : 4
Vues : 5933

Re: Can detached skimmers move with an action marker

Yes, I would think so, there is nothing in the rules that forbids it. In fact given that supports of counter chargers can also make a move and even charge when their dividion is activated would tend to lend itself to that conclusion.
cheers
Jim
par gibbyj
lun. 4 mai 2020 13:47
Forum : Questions
Sujet : Support d'artillerie
Réponses : 1
Vues : 3353

Re: Support d'artillerie

Yes
p48 4th bullet on right column.
par gibbyj
lun. 4 mai 2020 10:50
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Orientation of artillery after unlimbering
Réponses : 8
Vues : 9263

Re: Orientation of artillery after unlimbering

I don't see why it couldn't be faced in any direction you choose. In the English version it has "Unlimbered(or deployed) artillery can make a reorientation in place(up to 180 degrees) and fire" page 39. It seems sensible to me that this covers Artillery that is already Unlimbered and artillery that ...
par gibbyj
lun. 4 mai 2020 10:02
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : When does artillery fire, limber, move penalty -1 apply
Réponses : 6
Vues : 7389

Re: When does artillery fire, limber, move penalty -1 apply

The +1 is for stationary throughout the turn, so I don't agree with the stationary bonus if you prep then move and the -1 is for limbering or unlimbering and yes if it has to return fire it will have an action marker and get -1.

cheers
Jim
par gibbyj
lun. 4 mai 2020 07:01
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : When does artillery fire, limber, move penalty -1 apply
Réponses : 6
Vues : 7389

Re: When does artillery fire, limber, move penalty -1 apply

Its a good question, an example in the main rules would have been good. I'm pretty sure this was debated on the French forum but no consensus or ruling made. For me, its either of Fire at -1 in Prep because you know your going to move, then limber and move in the Movement phase. or Fire in the Movem...
par gibbyj
dim. 3 mai 2020 21:26
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Prep Fire
Réponses : 10
Vues : 12273

Re: Prep Fire

No, I said you can move, unlimber and fire. I said nothing about prep fire, limber and move. I'm not sure the rules are clear on how that works. Whereas I'm pretty sure Herve has clarified the former. I wouldn't have a problem with prep,limber move if that's the way it is. I would have a problem wit...
par gibbyj
dim. 3 mai 2020 14:46
Forum : Rules questions
Sujet : Prep Fire
Réponses : 10
Vues : 12273

Re: Prep Fire

An artillery can move, unlimber and fire depending on class, but it wouldn't be in the prep fire phase as the move would be in the movement phase which is after the prep fire phase.
cheers
Jim