Commanders

[rpm]

With regard to commanders, the rule book mentions a CinC, (army or corps commander) and division commanders who recieve their orders from the CinC. Yet, I've noticed that in several scenarios (Teugen Hausen for example) that the army lists has both division and the individual brigade commnders, while other scenarios do not. My question is do these brigade commanders also roll for CP's? Can division commanders transfer CP's to subordinate brigade commanders? What criteria is used for including or not including them?

Thanks.
rpm.

[RogerGreenwood]

I would suggest that any game with 300 or fewer points would have only the C. in C rolling for C.P. Division commanders roll for their CP on activation. If there are too many points available for distribution by the C in C the mechanics of the order system will not work correctly. CP should be in short supply.

[volt.goat525]

I agree with this approach. Keeping CPs relatively scarce makes the command system more meaningful and prevents the CinC from having too many points to distribute. Having division commanders roll for CPs on activation also seems like a good way to represent a more decentralized command structure in larger games.

I think the main point that still needs clarification is the role of brigade commanders when they are specifically listed in a scenario. If they are included as commanders, it would be useful to know whether they generate their own CPs, receive CPs from their division commander, or are simply there for historical/scenario purposes.

text to csv convert txt to csv convert text to csv convert text file to csv text file to csv txt to csv converter пдф в пнг онлайн how to convert txt to excel convert txt file to excel txt file to excel txt to excel converter convert txt to xls txt to xls converter dst file .dst file dst converter dst file converter convert to dst convert dst file avif转jpg jpg to dxf jpg en dxf imagen a dwg convert jpg to dxf .jpg to dxf convert jpg to dxf autocad png to dds png a dds png to .dds convert png to dds png to dss .png to .dds png to epub convert png to epub png to epub converter free online converter png to epub ogg a wav .ogg to wav ogg to wave convertir ogg a wav ogg wav converter .ogg to .wav png to epub convert png to epub csv to text csv file to text convert csv to txt csv to txt file convert csv to text convert csv to text file jar to zip .jar to .zip zip to jar zip to jar file zip to jar converter .jar to zip azw3 to epub converting an awz3 to epub convert azw3 to epub convert awz3 to epub converter azw3 to epub png a cur convert cur .cur converter png to cur converter .png to .cur convert png to cur pak to bin converter pak to bin converter online convert pak to bin convert pak to bin online free convert pak to bin online bin converter png to dxf converter png in dxf png to stp png into dxf png to dwg converter png to dxf converter free online converter .html to ppt convert .html to powerpoint convert html to ppt html to powerpoint converter html to ppt converter convert html into ppt dxf to svg convert dxf to svg dxf to svg converter dxf svg converter jpeg to bmp jpeg to .bmp jpeg to bitmap conversion jpeg to bitmap jiff to png jif to png docx to png docx png dox to png docx en png docx a png convert xls to txt excel to text format convert xls to text convert excel to txt excel to txt xls to txt rtf to txt convert rtf to txt rtf to txt converter

[rpm]

I agree. That was my source of confusion. What role do the brigade commanders play in the rules? Since they are listed with ratings in the scenarios, this would suggest that they roll for their own CP's. Since my interest is in early Revolutionary battles, I think I'll just stick with the CinC and Divisional commanders. I think this would more accurately reflect the inefficient command structure of the Ancien Regime armies of the period.